Tuesday, June 17, 2008

Unofficial impact factors

Biomed Central has calculated unofficial impact factors for many of its titles that are not yet covered in Journal Citation Reports -- they used ISI data to figure out the IFs for ~100 BMC titles. Seems like a great way to work around the delay between when a journal begins publication and when ISI begins tracking/calculating IFs.

More here on the Biomed Central blog and here on the BMC Impact Factor FAQ.

Labels: ,

Sunday, April 22, 2007

Weekend variety post: EBM, Open Medicine, safety, research reproducibility

Cleaning out some of my saved Google alerts...

- BBC News: "Busting modern medical myths" - brief quotes from Andrew Booth and Paul Glasziou about evidence-based medicine
- News item, "Cochrane researcher admits lid law may decrease bike use," about a recent Cochrane review which found that legislation to promote helmet use among bicyclists was associated with a reduction in injuries, but noted that the lack of high-quality evidence on the topic made it impossible to rule out the possibility that the reduction was due to decreased bicycling rather than safer bicycling.
- a news item, "Now you can read what doctors see," marketing the new Canadian open access title Open Medicine to patients
- An Annals of Internal Medicine piece, Reproducible Research: Moving toward Research the Public Can Really Trust," discussing one strategy for reducing the possibility of research improprieties making it into the peer-reviewed literature, the concept of research reproducibility, defined briefly in the paper: "Reproducibility involves methods to ensure that independent scientists can reproduce published results by using the same procedures and data as the original investigators. It also requires that the primary investigators share their data and methodological details. These include, at a minimum, the original protocol, the dataset used for the analysis, and the computer code used to produce the results. "
- Related to the above Annals piece, the authors of the Iraq mortality study published in Lancet last October have made their dataset available to other researchers, with some restrictions on use that are also causing controversy (see this post by Tim Lambert of Deltoid and the associated comments)

And finally, a public service announcement-type link (via Boing Boing): why you should wear your seatbelt - Author Jim Macdonald, who is also a paramedic, sums it up nicely -
In a collision, you have three or four sub-collisions all taking place in sequence. First, the vehicle hits some object. The vehicle abruptly slows, but unrestrained objects inside it continue at the same speed, in the same direction. Then the unrestrained body hits the interior of the vehicle, and starts to slow. That’s the second collision. That body’s internal organs are still moving at speed until they hit the inside of the chest (or get cheese-sliced by their supporting ligaments—and that’s where you get things like bisected livers or aortas). The fourth collision is when the bowling ball you left on the rear deck hits you in the back of the head, because that continued at the same speed in the same direction. Newtonian physics: Learn it, live it, love it.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, October 02, 2006

Open access and peer review

A few periodicals with fairly different takes on a recent Associated Press story about open access, PLoS and PLoS One, and Nature's new open review experiment --

Wired News: Web journals take on peer review

Boston Herald: Online journals threaten traditional scientific peer-review system

Washington Times: Internet journals offer researchers quick publishing

Looking at the results of a Google News search seems to indicate that most of the media titles that have picked up this story have focused on the confrontation aspect.

Update:
Chris Surridge of PLoS One discusses the AP article on the PLoS One blog.

And thanks to Mark for pointing out these two links:
Peter Suber of Open Access News caught this too.

Seed went with a more subtle take on the confrontation aspect: "Free, For All: How will the open access movement affect global science?

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, September 24, 2006

Opposition to open access legislation

Senior academic officials from 10 academic institutions have sent a letter to the two senators (Cornyn, TX; Lieberman, CT) sponsoring the Federal Research Public Access Act (S.2695)

The letter comments:

"The free posting of unedited author manuscripts by government agencies threatens the integrity of the scientific record, potentially undermines the publisher peer review process, and is not a smart use of funds that could be better used for research...Mandating free dissemination of scientific manuscripts within six months would significantly limit the ability of non-profit and commercial publishers to cover the upfront reviewing, editing, and production costs of creating these manuscripts. Some journals would simply cease to exist. Others would be much less able to support innovation in scientific publishing and archiving. Ultimately, this could lead to a system in which NIH and other federal agencies must sustain a significant portion of the research publishing enterprise, maintaining 100+ years of archival journals, as well as producing new research articles."

The Library of Congress provides several links to further description of the legislation and related documents.

Contrary to the initial focus of the letter, it's hard to see how the following text from the legislation would subvert peer review:
"Each Federal research public access policy shall provide for--
(1) submission to the Federal agency of an electronic version of the author's final manuscript of original research papers that have been accepted for publication in peer-reviewed journals and result from research supported, in whole or in part, from funding by the Federal Government;

(2) the incorporation of all changes resulting from the peer review publication process in the manuscript described under paragraph (1);

(3) the replacement of the final manuscript with the final published version if--

(A) the publisher consents to the replacement; and

(B) the goals of the Federal agency for functionality and interoperability are retained;

(4) free online public access to such final peer-reviewed manuscripts or published versions as soon as practicable, but not later than 6 months after publication in peer-reviewed journals;

(5) production of an online bibliography of all research papers that are publicly accessible under the policy, with each entry linking to the corresponding free online full text; and

(6) long-term preservation of, and free public access to, published research findings

The legislation also explicitly excludes material that is not peer reviewed, including:

(1) laboratory notes, preliminary data analyses, notes of the author, phone logs, or other information used to produce final manuscripts;

(2) classified research, research resulting in works that generate revenue or royalties for authors (such as books) or patentable discoveries, to the extent necessary to protect a copyright or patent; or

(3) authors who do not submit their work to a journal or works that are rejected by journals.
I can see how this may hurt scientific publishing financially, but the text of the proposed legislation seems to be in line with the traditional peer review process. The legislation also seems to parallel similar efforts, already nationally mandated, in the UK to facilitate public access to the results of publicly-funded research (see this previous post).

Update:
T. Scott provides an interesting commentary and suggestions re: the economic aspects of the debate and the potential detrimental nature of partisanship on the issue (i.e. "us vs. them" arguments).

Labels: , ,

Sunday, September 17, 2006

Biomed Central survey of funder policies on open access

Biomed Central has released initial results from a survey of major biomedical research funding agencies regarding their support for and policies regarding open access publishing.

Their summary of findings so far (33 responses from 75 funding agencies surveyed):
- 31 funders have confirmed that they are willing to fund article processing charges
- 16 funders are signatories of one of the major international declarations in support of open access
- 15 funders have an official policy in support of open access
- 11 of these funder policies encourage or in some cases require funding recipients to deposit resulting research articles in an open access repository

Labels: , , ,